Skip to main content

Super - Takumar 500mm F4.5 Manual Lens- Is it any good !

With my impulsive buying getting better of me , i recently won on ebay  a super- takumar 500mm f4..5 manual beast of a lens. Initially i was cursing myself to the core , why on earth did i even  bid on the same? Post winning i browsed through eBay and found the price points of the same lens in other bids was significantly higher ( at least some respite ) . I paid for the same and waited for lens to arrive. All of my search on the lens and on images clicked using that did not help me much. I got more pictures on web of the lens itself instead of pictures clicked using it . Whatever limited pictures i could search raised my hopes  , and lens looked nothing but a stellar performer. Most of the reviews spoke about few negatives -
1. Heavy
2. Chromatic aberration.
3. Impractical for active wildlife.
4. MFD being 10 mts 

Well , so the lens arrived.. It had no dedicated lens case and was packed in a bubble wrap. I had to pay customs duty which made the lens almost around 26000 INR or USD 400 approximately . The box it came in did not seem (that) heavy .. and when i opened the box ...wow!!! what a BEAST of a lens it turned out to be. 

Compared to SAL 500mm F8 lens mirror , which happens to be my most priced possession just for its uniqueness, this really looked BIG. Fortunately i have an Alpha to screw mount adaptor (not the best quality which I realised later ) that  worked fine. 

Now I was ready to take photographs . I realised one thing the moment i setup the camera that your forearms need to be way too strong to go handheld with this lens. Mounted the same on tripod and clicked away some wi-fi antennas on the roof of adjoining buildings .. pics  didn't seem that bad.. but the moment i zoomed into the picture , Chromatic aberration was way too high for my comfort .This can be handled in post production .





Next were the pigeons and Mynas in our locality. Honestly, I am personally pleased with the results .. As far as my limited experience with the lens goes , all the reviews on this one are more or less accurate thgough. It is heavy for any handheld photography, is highly vulnerable to CA and Minimum Focus Distance (MFD) is certainly  way too high. Moreover to add to these, the lens did not fit the body as nicely as one would like it  to. It screws up in a manner that aperture and focal distance reading scales do not align to eye level  they are way too low on the circumference to be read properly. This is more i think to do with a sub standard alpha to screw mount adaptor . I am attaching some of the initial test shots i have taken with this lens. The lens undoubtedly is sharp, beating my expectation and on a day when you can sit in a watch tower or be stationary at one location , you can have a ball of a time. Absence of AF may hamper your active wildlife photography or birds in flight , but the lens surely deserves full marks on price/performance. Where can you get 500mm which is as fast as F4.5 at 400 USD. I am loving it!! Wilderness calling!! yet again !! 


Comments

Post a Comment

My Most Read Posts

Smooth Trans Focus (STF) Mode - A test shot using Minolta Dynax 7 .

STF Mode test shot using Dynax 7 . , a photo by arnavkhorana on Flickr. Minolta Dynax/Maxxum  7 's unique feature of  Smooth trans focus (STF) effect certainly gives amazing bokeh and a "POP UP " effect . 7 shots at varying apertures are taken on single frame.. so tripod is must and object should be stationary . Use a tripod , keep the object stationary .. in case you are working with a model you might need to ensure that he/she does not  even bat an eyelid. As the 7 shots can take considerable amount of time ( in a second or so ) humans may sway a little  resulting in motion blur . This latency limits the use of this feature a little but having said that the effect is truly worth trying !!! and  .. if the background is at certain distance .. the "3D or Pop up " effect is more profound .  I haven't used the Sony 135mm STF Lens , so cant compare the effect of dynax/maxxum 7 and the one produced by th specialized lens. Nevertheless the feature is ve...

Sunset and the Young Moon in an urban landscape !!